This is a short post but worth sharing. You probably already know this but bears reminding. We once had a candidate who came in for a pretty competitive position, meaning there were several very good applicants. He had the traits you would want – great understanding of the position and skills needed to succeed, relevant experience in a similar industry, strong “toolbelt” of skills relevant to the role, seasoned people management experience, and strong communication skills. Still, he blew the interview and never got an offer. Why?
He talked about his existing employer in a negative fashion too frequently. Yes, in some (or many) situations it’s okay to state up front that you are looking for a new situation. Maybe your company is laying off people left and right, maybe your company got acquired or went through a merger and there is no longer a “fit”, or maybe the company moved. All of those are legit and you can still paint them in a non-negative light.
This candidate had been at a very successful company for some time, yet it was undergoing change to adapt to the market. He simply got caught up with what I call the “good old days” syndrome; he couldn’t help himself from bringing up examples of how they used to do things and the new changes just weren’t working.
Needless to say, many interviewers caught on to this and it was enough of a negative where the hiring manager decided the candidate was not worth pursuing. No manager wants to hire a complainer – most people are great when things are going their way, but how will they react when or if things go south, even if temporarily.
It just goes to show even the smallest things can cost you an offer…so don’t complain about former employers or even portray them in a bad way (even if it is justified). It shows a lack of common sense, especially in an interview. Of course, this seems obvious but I have seen this occurrence happen time and time again over the years – I can’t remember a single one of those candidates ever being hired either!